Choose one of the following scenarios which illustrate a variety of incidents that have occurred on a university campus.Imagine that you are a residence hall counselor on campus, and the student described in the incident has come to you to ask for advice.
What sort of advice would you give to the student?
Explain why your advice represents the best course of action for the student to follow.
Scenario:Jim is an 18-year-old white student living away from home for the first time. He and his girlfriend were hanging out at the park when they noticed a car pull into the empty parking lot. No one got out of the car for nearly an hour, and it was getting dark. Jim and his girlfriend had planned to stay a while longer, but the car made them feel nervous. As they left the park, they passed nearby the car, and Jim knocked on the window to see if the occupants needed any help. As the window rolled down, Jim noticed that the men were black. He said, “Hey, what’s up? What are you guys doing here?” One of the men was insulted, became angry, and stated that they had every right to be in the parking lot. He claimed that Jim was racially profiling them. He has gone to the campus mediation center to report the incident and is demanding that Jim formally apologize. Jim is very upset because he feels he is being unfairly called a racist
Jim, it sounds like you’re in a tough spot, and it’s understandable that you’re upset. This situation is definitely complicated, and it’s good that you’re thinking about how to handle it. Here’s my advice:
Acknowledge the other person’s perspective: Even if you didn’t intend to be racist, it’s important to acknowledge that the men in the car felt they were being racially profiled. Their experience is valid, even if you don’t agree with their interpretation of your actions. Try to see it from their point of view. They were sitting in a car, minding their own business, and you approached them with a “what are you guys doing here?” which, given the racial context, could easily be interpreted as suspicion based on their race.
Take responsibility for your actions: While you may not have meant it that way, your question, “What are you guys doing here?” combined with the fact that they were Black men in a parked car, created a situation where they felt targeted. It’s not about labeling yourself a racist, but about recognizing how your actions were perceived.
Consider mediation seriously: The fact that they’ve gone to the campus mediation center is actually a good opportunity. Mediation isn’t about deciding who’s right and who’s wrong. It’s a chance for both sides to explain their perspectives and understand how their actions affected the other person. It can be a powerful way to build understanding and potentially repair the relationship.
Focus on learning and growth: This is a learning experience. Think about how you could have handled the situation differently. Perhaps a simple “Is everything alright?” or even just leaving them alone would have been better. We all make mistakes, but the important thing is to learn from them.
Reflect on your own biases: We all have biases, even if we don’t realize it. This situation might be a good time to reflect on your own assumptions and how they might have influenced your actions. There are resources on campus that can help with this, like workshops on diversity and inclusion.
Why this is the best course of action:
It’s important to remember that this isn’t about being “right” or “wrong.” It’s about understanding, learning, and growing. I’m here to support you through this process.