Characteristics of experimental and nonexperimental quantitative research.
In your initial post, consider the following:
Compare and contrast the characteristics of experimental and nonexperimental quantitative research.
State the research question the researchers were trying to answer in the study.
Identify the type of quantitative research design that was used in the assigned study.
Evaluate whether the researchers’ conclusion follows logically from the evidence presented.
Identify threats to internal and external validity that might apply to how this study was conducted.
Determine whether validity threats were addressed by the researchers. If so, describe how this was done.
Summarize ethical considerations that were mentioned in the research report.
Assess what ethical considerations apply to the design of the study but that were not mentioned by the researchers.
Explain how you might do a study on this topic differently and why your approach would be more appropriate than the one used by the researchers.
Sample Solution
In experimental research, variables are the specific characteristics or factors that are manipulated and measured in order to test a hypothesis. Non-experimental research observes variables in their natural state instead of manipulating them. One of the main differences between experimental and non-experimental research is the level of control the researcher has over the variables. In experimental research, the researcher has complete control over the independent variable and can manipulate it to test the hypothesis. In non-experimental research, the researcher does not have this level of control and must rely on observations and measurements of naturally occurring variables.
Experimental Quantitative Research
- Characteristics:
- The researcher manipulates one or more variables.
- The researcher randomly assigns participants to treatment and control groups.
- The researcher measures the dependent variable before and after the treatment.
- Strengths:
- The researcher can make causal inferences about the relationship between the independent and dependent variables.
- The results of experimental research are more generalizable than the results of nonexperimental research.
- Weaknesses:
- Experimental research can be difficult and time-consuming to conduct.
- Experimental research may not be ethical in some cases.
- Characteristics:
- The researcher does not manipulate any variables.
- The researcher does not randomly assign participants to groups.
- The researcher measures the dependent variable at one point in time.
- Strengths:
- Nonexperimental research is often easier and less time-consuming to conduct than experimental research.
- Nonexperimental research can be conducted in real-world settings.
- Weaknesses:
- The researcher cannot make causal inferences about the relationship between the independent and dependent variables.
- The results of nonexperimental research may not be generalizable.
- Does the use of a specific teaching method improve student test scores?