Why has more progress been made on customer value differentiation than on customer needs differentiation?
Is it possible to meet individual needs? Is it feasible? Can you describe three examples where it has been profitable?
For each of the following product categories, name a branded example, then hypothesize about how you might categorize customers by their different needs.
Automotive
Airlines
Personal Care (cosmetics, deodorant, toothpaste, etc.)
Hotels
Connect the chapter from ‘Every Good Endeavor’ called ‘The Design of Work’ to ONE of the examples you provided. For example, a Louis Vuitton handbag holds important items for their consumers from their money and credit cards and many other daily essentials. But a handbag from Walmart works just as effectively. Why is there such a following for Louis Vuitton then? Y
Several factors contribute to the greater progress made in customer value differentiation compared to needs differentiation:
1. Measurability: Value is easier to quantify than needs. Metrics like revenue, profit margin, and customer lifetime value provide tangible measures of value differentiation. Quantifying specific needs, however, can be subjective and nuanced, making it difficult to track and validate the success of needs-based strategies.
2. Scalability: Value-based segmentation caters to broader groups with shared value propositions, leading to economies of scale. Needs-based approaches often involve highly customized and personalized solutions, making them resource-intensive and less scalable.
3. Focus on Profitability: Businesses prioritize financial sustainability, and value differentiation offers a clearer path to increased profitability. Needs-based differentiation might require sacrificing short-term gains for long-term loyalty and advocacy, which can be a tough sell in a profit-driven environment.
Meeting Individual Needs: Feasible with Focused Strategies
While fully meeting every individual’s need might be impractical, it’s certainly possible to cater to specific needs within segments defined by commonalities. This requires:
Profitable Examples of Needs-Based Differentiation:
Niche Retailers: Companies like Casper cater to the specific needs of sleep-deprived consumers by offering high-quality mattresses with convenient online delivery and returns. This focus on a specific need has garnered them a loyal following and strong financial performance.
Luxury Brands: Companies like Rolls-Royce prioritize personalization and bespoke experiences, meeting the individual needs of affluent customers seeking exclusivity and customization. This strategy has not only built brand loyalty but also commanded premium prices, leading to significant profitability.
Subscription Services: Services like HelloFresh cater to the diverse dietary needs of their customers by offering personalized meal plans and ingredients delivered to their doorsteps. This focus on meeting individual preferences within the segment of home cooks has led to explosive growth and profitability.
Product Category Needs Segmentation:
Connecting “The Design of Work” to Louis Vuitton:
The chapter on “The Design of Work” emphasizes the importance of crafting fulfilling work experiences. Louis Vuitton handbags, beyond their utility, resonate with customers due to the craftsmanship, heritage, and brand identity they represent. Owning a Louis Vuitton bag becomes a statement about personal taste, values, and aspirations. This intangible sense of fulfillment adds intrinsic value and justifies the premium price, attracting a devoted customer base despite the availability of equally functional alternatives.
In conclusion, while customer value differentiation remains the dominant approach, understanding and catering to specific needs presents unique opportunities for businesses to build loyalty, foster advocacy, and ultimately achieve financial success. By conducting in-depth customer research, implementing targeted segmentation strategies, and embracing flexibility, businesses can tap into the power of needs-based differentiation and create offerings that truly resonate with their diverse clientele.