Strategic Situation Between Players.
In business, sports, politics, and many other fields there are probably countless situations akin to the prisoner's dilemma where players acting in their own self-interest do not produce an ideal outcome. Likewise, some player dynamics also illustrate other game theory concepts like a game of chicken, credible threats/commitments, and other similar concepts. Use at least one article from The Wall Street Journal to discuss a strategic situation between players that resembled or used any of the concepts above. What could have any of the players done differently to achieve a better outcome?
Sample Solution
The Airline Price War: A Prisoner's Dilemma Takes Flight ()
The airline industry is a prime example of situations resembling the prisoner's dilemma. A recent Wall Street Journal article titled "The Airline Price War That Wasn't" (June 20, 2023) details how major airlines avoided a price war despite the temptation to undercut competitors.
Prisoner's Dilemma in Action:
Imagine two airlines, Airline A and Airline B, in a market. They can either set high prices (Cooperate) or start a price war with low fares (Defect).
- Cooperate (High Prices): If both airlines maintain high prices, they earn healthy profits.
- Defect (Low Prices): If one airline cuts prices, it attracts more customers but reduces profit margins. The other airline can either match the low price (suffering losses) or maintain high prices (losing customers).
- Capacity Management: Airlines strategically adjusted flight schedules to avoid oversupply and maintain some upward pressure on prices.
- Focus on High-Value Customers: Airlines offered targeted promotions and loyalty programs to retain high-paying business travelers.
- Consolidation: Mergers and acquisitions reduced the number of major players, leading to a more concentrated market where price wars are less likely.
- Transparency and Communication: Clearer communication between airlines about capacity management could further stabilize pricing.
- Focus on Customer Experience: Airlines could invest in improving in-flight services and amenities to differentiate themselves beyond just price.
- Innovation in Pricing Models: Exploring dynamic pricing models that adjust fares based on demand could offer a more nuanced approach than simply high or low prices.