Person-organization fit or person-job fit
at
When hiring an employee, which do you believe is more important: person-organization fit or person-job fit? Explain your rationale, and use examples if possible.
With your answer in mind, think about someone who you have worked with who was not a good fit and ended up leaving the organization. Share your insights as to why the individual left the organization. Please keep the person and organization anonymous.
Sample Solution
When hiring an employee, both person-organization fit and person-job fit are important considerations for employers to take into account. Person-organization fit is defined as the compatibility between an individual’s values, goals and attitudes with those of their prospective employer (Jackson et al., 2009). This form of evaluation looks at whether or not a candidate will be able to adapt effectively to a company’s culture while still being able to contribute positively in the long term; such traits can include possessing the necessary skills required but also having the right mindset that aligns with organizational objectives (Abrams & Marquez., 2018).
Person-job fit meanwhile refers to how well someone’s qualifications match up with what is needed for a certain position within a particular field (Ostroff & Bowen, 2000). In essence this evaluates how suitable an applicant may be in terms of performing tasks expected from them based on their experiences or educational background. Thus, when deciding which factor should be prioritized more it is best practice for organizations to consider both aspects equally as this creates balance between those who have potential yet need training versus those who possess an adequate level of prior knowledge but may not necessarily share similar values when compared against existing employees or company ideals.
