A vehicle that had veered off the road and struck a parked vehicle

at
Categories
Tags

 

While on roving patrol during the evening shift, you come across a vehicle that had veered off the road and struck a parked vehicle. When you approach the vehicle, you immediately recognize that the driver is Captain Jones from your department who was driving his wife’s vehicle. Assume that Captain Jones’ behavior and actions clearly suggest that he is intoxicated.
Should you arrest Captain Jones, assuming that he subsequently failed the field sobriety test, or should you call his wife to pick him up? Explain how you would proceed and why. (Be sure to showcase your critical thinking skills when explaining “why.”)

Sample Solution

The arrest of Captain Jones is a complex situation with ethical and legal implications. While it is important to uphold the law and ensure public safety, it is also crucial to handle the situation with professionalism and respect for the captain’s position.

Here’s how I would proceed:

  1. Prioritize Public Safety: The immediate concern is to ensure that the scene is safe and that there are no further injuries. I would take steps to secure the area and direct traffic around the accident.
  2. Administer Field Sobriety Test: Given Captain Jones’ behavior and the circumstances of the accident, I would administer a field sobriety test to assess his level of intoxication. If he fails the test, it would provide strong evidence of his impairment.
  3. Contact the Watch Commander: I would immediately contact the watch commander to inform them of the situation and request guidance. The watch commander can provide direction on how to proceed, considering the captain’s position and the potential consequences of the arrest.
  4. Consider the Legal and Ethical Implications:
    • Professional Responsibility: As a law enforcement officer, I have a duty to uphold the law and ensure public safety. This includes arresting individuals who are driving under the influence, regardless of their position.
    • Departmental Policies: I would review departmental policies and procedures regarding the arrest of fellow officers. These policies may outline specific guidelines for handling such situations.
    • Potential Consequences: I would consider the potential consequences of arresting a fellow officer, including disciplinary action or damage to the department’s reputation.
  5. Make an Informed Decision: Based on the evidence, departmental policies, and the potential consequences, I would make a decision whether to arrest Captain Jones or take other appropriate action. If the evidence strongly suggests that he is driving under the influence and there is no compelling reason not to arrest him, I would proceed with the arrest.

Ultimately, the decision to arrest Captain Jones should be based on the principle of treating all individuals equally under the law, regardless of their position or rank. While it may be difficult to arrest a fellow officer, it is essential to prioritize public safety and maintain the integrity of the law enforcement profession.

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer