Sexual Morality

 

After reading the selections for this topic, discuss how natural law theory, Kantian deontology and utilitarianism would address sexual behavior. You may choose to focus on a specific type of behvaior, i.e. same-sex marriage, homosexuality, prostitution, etc., or you may focus on sexual behavior writ large. As always, please be respectful of your peers, and focus on the readings in your answers.

 

 

 

Week 6B: Equality and Discrimination

After doing the readings for this topic, answer the following question:

Should racial, gender, or other differences ever be relevant in making decisions about qualified candidates for jobs or educational opportunities? Make sure to support your answer with reference to the concepts discussed in the chapter.

 

Sample Solution

Natural Law Theory

Natural law theory posits that there are universal moral laws that are inherent in nature and can be discovered through reason. These laws are considered to be objective and binding on all individuals, regardless of cultural or societal beliefs.

Regarding sexual behavior, natural law theory would likely focus on the inherent purpose of sexuality within a natural order. Traditional interpretations of natural law often view sexual behavior as intended for procreation within the context of marriage. Deviations from this norm, such as same-sex marriage, homosexuality, or prostitution, might be considered morally wrong based on their perceived inconsistency with the natural purpose of sexuality.

Kantian Deontology

Kantian deontology emphasizes the importance of categorical imperatives, which are universal moral principles that should be followed regardless of the consequences. Kant argued that individuals should act in accordance with principles that they would want to be universal laws.

In the context of sexual behavior, Kantian deontology would likely focus on the principle of treating individuals as ends in themselves, rather than merely as means to an end. This suggests that sexual behavior should be based on mutual respect, consent, and the recognition of the inherent dignity of all individuals. While Kant did not explicitly address issues such as same-sex marriage or homosexuality, his emphasis on respect and autonomy could be interpreted to support these behaviors.

Utilitarianism

Utilitarianism is a consequentialist ethical theory that focuses on maximizing overall happiness or utility. It argues that morally right actions are those that produce the greatest good for the greatest number of people.

In the context of sexual behavior, utilitarianism would likely evaluate different types of behavior based on their potential consequences for individual happiness and societal well-being. For example, if same-sex marriage promotes happiness and well-being for same-sex couples, and does not have any significant negative consequences for others, then utilitarianism would support it. Similarly, if prostitution is deemed to harm individuals or society, then utilitarianism would likely oppose it.

Racial, Gender, or Other Differences in Job or Educational Opportunities

Racial, gender, or other differences should never be relevant in making decisions about qualified candidates for jobs or educational opportunities. Such discrimination is fundamentally unjust and violates principles of equality and fairness.

Kantian deontology, in particular, emphasizes the importance of treating individuals as ends in themselves, regardless of their race, gender, or other characteristics. To discriminate against someone based on these factors would be to treat them as means to an end, rather than recognizing their inherent dignity.

Utilitarianism also supports non-discrimination, as discrimination can lead to negative consequences for individuals and society as a whole. By promoting diversity and inclusion, organizations can create more equitable and productive environments.

Conclusion

While natural law theory, Kantian deontology, and utilitarianism offer different perspectives on sexual behavior, they all share a commitment to ethical principles and respect for individual dignity. When making decisions about job or educational opportunities, it is essential to avoid discrimination based on irrelevant factors such as race, gender, or other differences.

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer