The major historical factors that affected the evolution of the U.S. Naval Service between the Spanish-American War

at
Categories
Tags

 

 

What were the major historical factors that affected the evolution of the U.S. Naval Service between the Spanish-American War and the end of World War I? Identify which historical factor was most important (what historians would term the primary causal factor) and justify your selection.
How did U.S. Naval strategic planning evolve in response to the shifting geostrategic situation the United States faced during the 1930s? In your discussion of overall Naval strate

The major historical factors that affected the evolution of the U.S. Naval Service between the Spanish-American War

gic planning, be sure to include the role of the Marine Corps.
Discuss how, in terms of strategy and major operations, the U.S. Naval Service fought against Germany and fascist Italy in the Atlantic and Mediterranean theaters during World War II. Also, discuss the Battle of the Atlantic and the reasons that the United States and Allies were successful there.

Section B Service-Specific Question (20% of the exam grade)
Select and answer the question for your Service. In writing your answer, draw upon the Service-specific readings assigned in Modules 1 through 4. Be sure to answer all parts of the question you select.
U.S. Navy and U.S. Coast Guard Students
From World War I through World War II, the roles of women, African-Americans, and other service members of color were limited by policy and prejudice. Was the Navy’s handling of the Port Chicago Disaster, as well as its policies regarding WAVES during World War II, opportunistic and exploitative of women and minorities, or were they critical factors for change within the Navy? Pick one side of the argument to defend and support your answer with historical evidence.

Sample Solution

Part A: U.S. Naval Service Evolution and Strategy

Historical Factors Shaping the U.S. Navy (Spanish-American War to WWI)

Several significant historical factors shaped the evolution of the U.S. Naval Service between the Spanish-American War and the end of World War I:

  1. The Spanish-American War: This conflict highlighted the need for a powerful navy to protect U.S. interests overseas. The war demonstrated the importance of naval power in projecting force and securing sea lanes.
  2. The Rise of the United States as a World Power: The U.S. emerged as a global power in the early 20th century, necessitating a larger and more powerful navy to protect its interests worldwide.
  3. Technological Advancements: The development of new technologies, such as the dreadnought battleship and the submarine, revolutionized naval warfare. The U.S. Navy had to adapt to these technological advancements to maintain its naval superiority.

Primary Causal Factor: The Spanish-American War

The Spanish-American War was a pivotal moment in the history of the U.S. Navy. It exposed the limitations of the pre-war navy and highlighted the need for a more powerful and modern fleet. The war’s outcome, which resulted in the acquisition of overseas territories, further solidified the U.S. Navy’s role as a global power.

U.S. Naval Strategic Planning in the 1930s

In the 1930s, the U.S. Navy faced a complex geopolitical landscape, characterized by the rise of aggressive powers like Germany, Italy, and Japan. The Navy’s strategic planning focused on:

  • Fleet Rebuilding: The U.S. Navy embarked on a massive shipbuilding program to modernize its fleet and increase its capacity.
  • Strategic Deployment: The Navy developed strategies for deploying its fleet to critical regions, such as the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans.
  • Naval Aviation: The development of naval aviation was a key priority, as aircraft carriers became essential for naval power projection.
  • Cooperation with Allies: The U.S. Navy worked closely with the British Royal Navy to coordinate naval operations and share intelligence.

The Marine Corps played a crucial role in the U.S. Navy’s strategic planning, particularly in amphibious operations. Marines were trained to conduct landings on hostile shores and secure beachheads for subsequent military operations.

U.S. Naval Strategy in World War II

In the Atlantic and Mediterranean theaters, the U.S. Navy focused on two primary objectives:

  1. Protecting Allied Shipping: The Battle of the Atlantic was a critical struggle between Allied and Axis forces. German U-boats posed a serious threat to Allied shipping, and the U.S. Navy played a crucial role in protecting convoys and hunting down submarines.
  2. Supporting Allied Landings: The U.S. Navy provided essential naval gunfire support and amphibious assault capabilities to support Allied landings in North Africa and Italy.

The U.S. Navy’s success in the Atlantic and Mediterranean theaters can be attributed to several factors:

  • Technological Superiority: The U.S. Navy possessed advanced technology, including radar, sonar, and aircraft carriers.
  • Strong Leadership: Effective leadership and strategic planning were crucial to the Navy’s success.
  • Allied Cooperation: Close cooperation with the British Royal Navy and other Allied navies was essential.
  • Industrial Capacity: The U.S. industrial base provided the resources to build and maintain a powerful fleet.

Part B: The U.S. Navy and the Port Chicago Disaster

The Port Chicago disaster was a tragic event that highlighted the Navy’s discriminatory practices and its exploitation of minority service members. African American sailors were disproportionately assigned to dangerous and hazardous duties, such as loading ammunition onto ships. The explosion at Port Chicago resulted in the deaths of hundreds of sailors, many of whom were Black.

While the Navy’s response to the disaster was initially inadequate, the incident ultimately led to significant changes in the way the Navy treated minority service members. The Navy was forced to address issues of racial discrimination and to provide better training and safety measures for all sailors.

In conclusion, while the Navy’s handling of the Port Chicago disaster was initially problematic, it ultimately led to positive changes within the organization. The Navy’s decision to integrate women into its ranks during World War II, through the WAVES program, also represented a significant step forward. However, it is important to acknowledge the historical injustices and discriminatory practices that have shaped the Navy’s past and to work towards a more inclusive and equitable future.

This question has been answered.

Get Answer