Leaders at your agency for victim support services

 

 

Leaders at your agency for victim support services have asked the victim advocates to give presentations at an upcoming meeting of the city council or state legislature to advocate for improvements to community policing. Your agency wants to show the city or state leaders the current, accurate data that supports their claim that a particular demographic group has been disproportionately targeted or treated unethically by community policing practices and is in need of change.

Preparation
Refer to the gender, racial, or ethnic group you selected in your Wk 2: State Demographic Data assignment. This group should be represented in the prison demographics for your state and will be your focus as you examine the influence of gender, racial, or ethnic aspects of diversity in community policing.

Research statistical demographic information on the imprisoned populations in your state or local area. (You may use the same resources from last week’s assignment.) Examine data for the racial, ethnic, or gender group that you choose to study. Access the Detailed Data Tool from The Sentencing Project for data on these groups.
Research at least 2 scholarly sources about issues in policing the selected gender, racial, or ethnic group.
Assessment Deliverable
Using data from your state or local area, create a 10- to 12-slide Microsoft® PowerPoint® presentation to city or state officials as if you were a victim advocate working on behalf of a community to recommend a plan for reducing disparity in the policing of minority groups.

Your presentation should include the following information with supportive examples from your research:

Cite relevant demographic information from state or local statistics on the race, ethnicity, or gender of the group you selected. Note any relevant disparities between groups.
Explain the roles of the various criminal justice agencies and representatives engaged in building rapport with the group you chose. Summarize the ethical responsibilities of criminal justice professionals to serve multicultural populations. Give an example of a risk to effective community policing that could occur based on an officer’s biases or lack of cultural competence with the selected population.
Identify aspects of multiculturalism and societal diversity to consider when policing this group. Describe how cultural, spiritual, or other factors may cause challenges for a minority defendant from this group during their interactions with law enforcement. Describe challenges to developing community policing practices impartial to gender, race, or ethnicity.
Propose at least 1 recommendation based on your findings for how to address the gender, racial, or ethnic disparity identified. Make a call to action for the city council or state legislature to implement changes based on your recommendation. (If no improvements are needed, recommend a strategy for maintaining the results that you identified.)

Sample Solution

lide 1: Title Slide

  • Title: Addressing Racial Disparities in Community Policing: A Call for Action
  • Your Agency Name
  • Date of Presentation

Slide 2: Introduction – The Need for Equitable Policing

  • Briefly introduce your agency and its mission to support victims.
  • State the purpose of the presentation: to highlight racial disparities in community policing impacting the African American/Black community and to propose recommendations for change.
  • Emphasize the importance of fair and ethical treatment for all community members.

(Speaker Notes: Briefly explain the agency’s role in advocating for justice and the well-being of all victims, including those who may be disproportionately affected by policing practices.)

Slide 3: Demographic Data: State Context

  • Title: Disparities in Incarceration: The African American/Black Community
  • Present hypothetical state-level data on the general population and incarcerated population for the African American/Black community compared to the White population. (Use a clear visual like a bar chart or table, similar to the example from last week).
  • Example Data (Hypothetical):
    • African American/Black General Population: 13%
    • African American/Black Prison Population: 38%
    • White General Population: 65%
    • White Prison Population: 35%
  • Clearly state the observed disparity: African Americans/Black individuals are significantly overrepresented in the state’s prison population compared to their representation in the general population.

(Speaker Notes: Explicitly state the numerical difference and the disparity index to highlight the extent of the issue. Reference the data source.)

Slide 4: Scholarly Research: Disproportionate Policing

  • Title: Evidence of Disparate Treatment
  • Summarize findings from at least two hypothetical scholarly sources that discuss issues in policing the African American/Black community.
  • Example 1 (Hypothetical Study): A study by [Hypothetical Author and Publication] found that African American/Black individuals are [X%] more likely to be stopped by police and [Y%] more likely to be arrested for similar offenses compared to White individuals in [State/Region].
  • Example 2 (Hypothetical Article): An article in [Hypothetical Journal] highlighted the impact of racial profiling and implicit bias in routine police encounters with African American/Black community members, leading to feelings of mistrust and alienation.

(Speaker Notes: Provide brief summaries of the key findings and methodologies of the cited research. Emphasize the link between policing practices and the observed demographic disparities.)

Slide 5: Roles in Building Community Rapport

  • Title: Collaborative Efforts for Community Trust
  • Explain the roles of various criminal justice agencies and representatives in building rapport with the African American/Black community:
    • Police Departments: Implementing community policing initiatives, engaging in dialogue, building trust through positive interactions.
    • Victim Support Services: Providing culturally competent support to victims within the community, acting as liaisons, and advocating for their needs.
    • Probation and Parole: Working to ensure fair and equitable supervision and reintegration.
    • Courts and Prosecutors: Ensuring fair and impartial legal processes.
    • Community Leaders and Organizations: Facilitating communication, providing cultural insights, and building bridges between law enforcement and the community.

(Speaker Notes: Provide specific examples of how each agency can actively engage with the African American/Black community to build trust and understanding.)

Slide 6: Ethical Responsibilities to Multicultural Populations

  • Title: Ethical Imperatives in Serving Diverse Communities
  • Summarize the ethical responsibilities of criminal justice professionals to serve multicultural populations:
    • Fairness and Impartiality: Treating all individuals with equality and without bias, regardless of race, ethnicity, or gender.
    • Respect for Diversity: Recognizing and valuing the cultural, linguistic, and experiential differences within the community.
    • Cultural Competence: Developing the knowledge, skills, and awareness necessary to interact effectively and respectfully with individuals from diverse backgrounds.
    • Integrity and Accountability: Maintaining high ethical standards and being accountable for actions that may disproportionately impact specific groups.

(Speaker Notes: Emphasize the importance of these ethical principles in building trust and legitimacy within the African American/Black community.)

Slide 7: Risks of Bias and Lack of Cultural Competence

  • Title: The Impact of Bias on Community Policing
  • Provide an example of a risk to effective community policing that could occur based on an officer’s biases or lack of cultural competence with the African American/Black population.
  • Example: An officer with implicit biases might interpret the behavior of a young African American/Black male as suspicious based on racial stereotypes, leading to an unnecessary stop and potential escalation. This negative interaction can erode trust within the community and hinder future cooperation with law enforcement. A lack of understanding of cultural communication styles might lead to misinterpretations and ineffective interactions during crisis intervention.

(Speaker Notes: Elaborate on the potential consequences of biased policing, including increased arrests, strained community relations, and a lack of cooperation in crime prevention.)

Slide 8: Aspects of Multiculturalism and Societal Diversity

  • Title: Understanding the Cultural Landscape
  • Identify aspects of multiculturalism and societal diversity to consider when policing the African American/Black community:
    • Historical context of systemic racism and its impact on trust.
    • Diverse socioeconomic backgrounds within the community.
    • Variations in cultural communication styles and norms.
    • The role of community leaders and influential figures.
    • Experiences of discrimination and marginalization.

(Speaker Notes: Explain how understanding these aspects can help officers approach interactions with greater sensitivity and effectiveness.)

Slide 9: Challenges for Minority Defendants

  • Title: Navigating the Justice System: Unique Challenges
  • Describe how cultural, spiritual, or other factors may cause challenges for an African American/Black defendant during their interactions with law enforcement:
    • Mistrust of authority figures due to historical experiences.
    • Language barriers or differences in communication styles leading to misunderstandings.
    • Spiritual or religious beliefs that might influence their understanding of legal processes.
    • Cultural norms around deference or assertiveness that could be misinterpreted.
    • Economic disparities affecting access to legal representation and resources.

(Speaker Notes: Provide specific examples to illustrate these challenges and their potential impact on fair treatment.)

Slide 10: Challenges to Impartial Community Policing

  • Title: Obstacles to Impartial Policing
  • Describe challenges to developing community policing practices impartial to gender, race, or ethnicity:
    • Implicit biases held by individual officers and within the organizational culture.
    • Systemic policies and practices that may have unintended discriminatory effects.
    • Lack of diversity within police forces.
    • Resistance to change and a lack of accountability for biased behavior.
    • Difficulty in measuring and addressing subjective factors like respect and fairness.

(Speaker Notes: Discuss the systemic and individual-level challenges that need to be addressed to achieve truly impartial community policing.)

Slide 11: Recommendation and Call to Action

  • Title: A Path Forward: Investing in Equitable Policing
  • Propose at least one recommendation based on your findings for how to address the identified racial disparity.
  • Example Recommendation: Implement mandatory and ongoing comprehensive implicit bias training and procedural justice training for all officers, with a focus on the historical context and lived experiences of the African American/Black community. This training should be developed and delivered in partnership with community stakeholders and include mechanisms for accountability and evaluation.
  • Make a clear call to action for the city council or state legislature to implement these changes, emphasizing the benefits for community trust, public safety, and equitable justice.

(Speaker Notes: Clearly articulate the desired action and the positive outcomes that are expected from its implementation. Emphasize the urgency and importance of addressing the identified disparities.)

Slide 12: Q&A and Contact Information

  • Open the floor for questions.
  • Provide contact information for your agency.

By following this outline and using concrete (even if hypothetical for this exercise) data and research, you can create a compelling presentation to advocate for meaningful changes in community policing practices to address racial disparities. Remember to replace the hypothetical information with your actual state or local data and findings from your scholarly research.

This question has been answered.

Get Answer
WeCreativez WhatsApp Support
Our customer support team is here to answer your questions. Ask us anything!
👋 Hi, Welcome to Compliant Papers.