Ancient Greece is often referred to as the “Cradle of Western Civilization”

at
Categories
Tags

 

Ancient Greece is often referred to as the “Cradle of Western Civilization” because of its political, cultural, and ideological contributions to the development of the Western World. In contrast from the neighboring empires and kingdoms of its time, Ancient Greece established its identity and sealed its legacy as an autonomous collection of city-states dedicated to the interest of the polis. Although we often single out Sparta as the heroic military power and Athens as the thriving cultural, economic, and democratic center…the collective Greek identity was much more complex and multi-faceted.

Post a response to the prompt below (5-7 sentences) and then reply to a classmate’s post (3-4 sentences). The reply should 1) extend your classmate’s post with further supporting evidence, or 2) respectfully disagree by offering counter-evidence. Simply typing “I agree” or “I disagree” is not enough.

Prompt: Agree or disagree with the following statements…

“In spite of her cultural, political, economic, and philosophical contributions, the glory of Ancient Greece is best defined by warfare. The autonomy of the Greek polis was first enabled thanks to the heroics of citizen soldiers (hoplite warriors), the classical achievements of the Golden Age (poetry, democratization, etc.) would never have occurred without the victories of the Persian Wars, and even her timeless philosophical contributions and ultimate downfall were direct results of the Peloponnesian War.”

Sample Solution

Disagree. While warfare was undoubtedly a significant aspect of Ancient Greece, it is an oversimplification to define the glory of Ancient Greece solely by its military achievements.

Here’s a breakdown of why:

  1. Cultural and Philosophical Contributions: The Greeks made immense contributions to fields like philosophy, art, literature, and science. These achievements were not merely byproducts of war but were driven by intellectual curiosity, creativity, and a desire to understand the world.
  2. Economic and Political Developments: The Greek polis, while often involved in conflict, also developed sophisticated economic systems, political structures, and legal frameworks. These achievements were not solely dependent on military prowess.
  3. The Role of Peace: Periods of peace were crucial for the development of Greek culture and civilization. During these times, trade flourished, intellectual exchange increased, and cities could focus on internal development.
  4. The Limitations of Military Might: While military victories were important, they did not guarantee long-term success. The Peloponnesian War, for example, ultimately weakened the Greek city-states and contributed to their decline.

Conclusion:

While warfare was a significant factor in Ancient Greek history, it is not the sole defining characteristic of its glory. The Greeks’ contributions to culture, philosophy, politics, and economics were equally, if not more, important in shaping their legacy.

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer