The avocado and artichoke ideas of the self are two contrasting philosophical approaches to understanding the nature of the self. The avocado idea of the self, also known as the modernist view, sees the self as a unified, coherent, and stable entity. It is often compared to an avocado, which has a hard outer shell and a soft, inner core. The core of the avocado represents the essential self, which is unchanging and universal.

The artichoke idea of the self, also known as the postmodern view, sees the self as fragmented, fluid, and constantly evolving. It is often compared to an artichoke, which has many layers that can be peeled away. There is no central core to the artichoke, and each layer represents a different aspect of the self.

The Avocado Idea of the Self

The avocado idea of the self is based on the belief that humans are rational beings. Reason is the core essence of the human self, and it is what distinguishes us from other animals. Reason allows us to think critically, solve problems, and make moral choices.

Plato and Aristotle were two of the most influential philosophers to promote the avocado idea of the self. Plato believed that the soul is immortal and that it contains a rational part. The rational part of the soul is the highest part, and it is what allows us to achieve wisdom and virtue.

Aristotle also believed that reason is the most important part of the human soul. He argued that reason is what allows us to distinguish between right and wrong, and it is what allows us to live a good life.

The Artichoke Idea of the Self

The artichoke idea of the self is based on the existential belief that our existence determines our essence. This means that there is no essential self that exists before our birth. Instead, the self is created through our experiences and interactions with the world.

Existentialists argue that we are free to choose our own destiny. We are not bound by any predetermined fate. However, this freedom also comes with responsibility. We are responsible for our own choices and for the consequences of those choices.

Soren Kierkegaard and Friedrich Nietzsche were two of the most influential philosophers to promote the artichoke idea of the self. Kierkegaard believed that the self is a subjective and individual experience. He argued that we cannot know the truth about ourselves or the world around us through reason alone. We must also rely on faith and intuition.

Nietzsche believed that the self is constantly evolving and changing. He argued that there is no essential self that remains the same throughout our lives. Instead, the self is a product of our experiences and our will to power.

Concerns About the Avocado Idea of the Self

Some people have expressed concern that the avocado idea of the self values reason over emotion. This view can lead to the suppression of emotions and to a denial of important aspects of the human experience.

The avocado idea of the self can also have negative implications for women. In Western culture, reason is often associated with men, while emotions are often associated with women. This can lead to the devaluation of women’s experiences and to the belief that women are less rational than men.

Am I an Avocado or an Artichoke?

It is difficult to say whether I am an avocado or an artichoke. I am still under development, and I am learning new things every day. I am beginning to understand the importance of reason, but I also recognize the importance of emotion and intuition.

I am also interested in non-Western views of the self. In some cultures, the self is seen as being more interconnected with others and with the natural world. This view is more in line with the artichoke idea of the self.

Conclusion

The avocado and artichoke ideas of the self are two contrasting philosophical approaches to understanding the nature of the self. The avocado idea of the self sees the self as a unified, coherent, and stable entity, while the artichoke idea of the self sees the self as fragmented, fluid, and constantly evolving.

There are both positive and negative aspects to both views. The avocado idea of the self can lead to a rational and disciplined life, but it can also lead to the suppression of emotions and to a denial of important aspects of the human experience. The artichoke idea of the self can lead to a more authentic and fulfilling life, but it can also lead to uncertainty and anxiety.

Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide which view of the self they find more compelling. There is no right or wrong answer.