Scenario
You are a juvenile justice professional who has been tasked with evaluating 15-year-old Philip’s case. Philip grew up in a tough, lower-socioeconomic neighborhood that was characterized by several cultures and high mobility. He never felt close to his parents, and he did not perform well in school. He valued such things as his fighting ability and his ability to con people. When he was 10 years old, he began to associate with delinquent peers who taught him how to steal cars and burglarize houses. He received rewards from his peers for his behavior and did not feel guilty for his delinquent acts. Instead, he would say that the people he stole from were wealthy enough to afford to replace the items, and most had insurance anyway.
Philip has been arrested for house burglary. He shows no sign of remorse for what he has done and is being disrespectful to the police officers. His parents are not cooperating with the police and the intake officer refuses to take Philip in, as there is a space crunch in the holding facility. The police let Philip go after giving him a warning. This is Philip’s first time in the juvenile justice system.
Assessment Preparation
Read the following literature reviews from the Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention (OJJDP) on problems faced by the police in handling juveniles:
“Community-Oriented Policing and Problem-Oriented Policing”
“Interactions Between Youth and Law Enforcement”
Assessment Deliverable
Write a 700- to 875-word report to the juvenile court, school authorities, community service providers, and the police department. Address the following in your report:
Identify a social theory that is most applicable to explain Philip’s behavior.
Describe the deterrence theory and explain how it is applicable in this situation.
Distinguish this crime as a status offense or a delinquent act.
Describe some procedures and safeguards that the police should follow when processing Philip’s case.
Determine which discretionary considerations the police should employ in this scenario.
Identify who must be informed of the seriousness of the charges once Philip is taken into custody.
Discuss police-based intervention programs that could help Philip deal with his delinquent behavior.
Juvenile Court Report Regarding Philip [Fictional Name], Case File [Fictional Number]
Date: March 27, 2025
To: The Honorable Juvenile Court, School Authorities of [Fictional School Name], Community Service Providers of Kisumu County, and the Kisumu County Police Department
From: [Your Name/Fictional Title, e.g., Juvenile Probation Officer, Social Worker]
Subject: Analysis of Behavior and Recommendations for Philip
This report is submitted to provide a comprehensive analysis of the behavior of Philip, a juvenile under the jurisdiction of this court, and to offer recommendations for intervention and support. This report will identify a relevant social theory to explain Philip’s actions, describe the deterrence theory and its applicability, and distinguish the alleged offense as either a status offense or a delinquent act.
Case Summary (Fictional for Illustrative Purposes):
Philip, a 16-year-old male, was recently apprehended by the Kisumu County Police Department following an incident at [Fictional School Name]. Allegations suggest that Philip was involved in the unauthorized removal and subsequent damage of school property, specifically several tablet computers from the school’s computer lab. Initial reports indicate that Philip acted in concert with two other peers. The motivation appears to be a desire for personal gain through the potential sale of the devices. Philip has no prior formal record with the juvenile court, although school authorities have noted a recent pattern of truancy and minor disruptive behavior.
Applicable Social Theory: Social Learning Theory
The social theory that appears most applicable to explain Philip’s behavior is Social Learning Theory, primarily developed by Albert Bandura. This theory posits that individuals learn behaviors through observation, imitation, and reinforcement within their social environment. It emphasizes that learning is a cognitive process that takes place in a social context and can occur purely through observation, even without direct motor reproduction or reinforcement.
In Philip’s case, several aspects of Social Learning Theory are relevant:
By understanding Philip’s actions through the lens of Social Learning Theory, interventions can be tailored to address his social environment, the role models he is exposed to,