Can free nicotine patches help smoking cessation by utilizing diffusion of innovations theory

 

Can free nicotine patches help smoking cessation by utilizing diffusion
of innovations theory?
Tobacco use and smoking continue to be public health problems
in the United States and around the world. Effective treatments
for quitting smoking are available, but many tobacco users and
smokers do not utilize them. In the United States, all 50 states
have set up quitlines. One quitline, the Oregon Tobacco Quit Line
(OTQL), used the diffusion of innovations theory to promote the
use of free nicotine patches (Deprey et al., 2009). The innovation
that the project had was free nicotine patches, which were distrib-
uted by the Oregon Free Patch Initiative (FPI). The FPI provided a
2-week nicotine patch starter kit free of charge to callers for 2 and
half months (time). The program used various communication
channels, including radio programs, word of mouth, emails, and
letters to public- and private-sector partners. The social systems
the program tapped included health plans, local policymakers,
media sources, and referral sources, such as healthcare provid-
ers. An evaluation of the program found that over a 3-month
period the FPI was able to get free news media coverage, was
successful in generating a 12-fold increase in calls to the quit-
line, sustained a twofold increase in the calls 5 months after the
program ended, and reached 1.3% of all smokers in the state of
Oregon. The researchers concluded that the distribution of free
nicotine patches utilizing the diffusion of innovations theory was
an effective way for quitlines to promote smoking cessation.
Deprey, M., McAfee, T., Bush, T., McClure, J. B., Zbikowski,
S., & Mahoney, L. (2009). Using free patches to improve
reach of the Oregon Quit Line. Journal of Public Health
Management and Practice, 15(5), 401–408.
Questions for Discussion
1. Can free nicotine patches help smoking cessation by utilizing
diffusion of innovations theory? Why or why not?
2. Was the diffusion of innovations theory adequately opera-
tionalized in this case study? What else could have been
done?

 

Sample Solution

Yes, free nicotine patches can help smoking cessation by utilizing diffusion of innovations theory. The Oregon Free Patch Initiative (FPI) described in the case study provides a successful example of this application. Here’s why:

Diffusion of Innovations theory:

This theory posits that the spread of new ideas or practices depends on five key factors:

  1. Relative advantage: Perceived benefit over existing solutions (free patches vs. paid patches).
  2. Compatibility: Aligning with existing values and practices (patches fit nicotine dependence treatment).
  3. Complexity: Ease of understanding and use (patches are relatively simple to use).
  4. Trialability: Ability to experiment without significant commitment (free patches offer low risk).
  5. Observability: Seeing others benefit from the innovation (media coverage and word-of-mouth promote success).

The FPI applied these factors effectively:

  • Relative advantage: Free patches offered a clear cost advantage over existing options.
  • Compatibility: Nicotine patches aligned with existing smoking cessation techniques.
  • Complexity: Patches are easy to use and require minimal instruction.
  • Trialability: The free starter kit removed the financial barrier to trying the product.
  • Observability: Media coverage and word-of-mouth reinforced the success of the program.

Evidence of successful diffusion:

  • 12-fold increase in calls to the quitline during the program.
  • Sustained double the call volume 5 months later.
  • Reached 1.3% of all smokers in Oregon.

Therefore, the case study demonstrates that free nicotine patches, strategically used within the diffusion of innovations framework, can effectively promote smoking cessation.

Potential improvements:

  • Target specific communities: Tailor messaging and outreach to populations with high smoking rates.
  • Partner with diverse organizations: Expand reach beyond healthcare providers to involve community groups.
  • Long-term sustainability: Develop funding strategies to maintain program beyond initial grants.
  • Measure specific outcomes: Track individual quit rates and long-term success, not just program reach.

Overall, the FPI case study provides a strong example of how free nicotine patches, combined with diffusion of innovations strategies, can significantly contribute to smoking cessation efforts. By addressing the limitations mentioned above, future initiatives can further improve their effectiveness and reach.

This question has been answered.

Get Answer
WeCreativez WhatsApp Support
Our customer support team is here to answer your questions. Ask us anything!
👋 Hi, Welcome to Compliant Papers.