Critical thinking skills in the psychopathology of mental health patients

at
Categories
Tags

 

 

Analyze and apply critical thinking skills in the psychopathology of mental health patients and provide treatment and health promotion while applying evidence-based research.

 

J.T. is a 20 year-old who reports to you that he feels depressed and is experiencing a significant amount of stress about school, noting that he’ll “probably flunk out.” He spends much of his day in his dorm room playing video games and has a hard time identifying what, if anything, is enjoyable in a typical day. He rarely attends class and has avoided reaching out to his professors to try to salvage his grades this semester. J.T. has always been a self-described shy person and has had a very small and cohesive group of friends from elementary through high school. Notably, his level of stress significantly amplified when he began college.

You learn that when meeting new people, he has a hard time concentrating on the interaction because he is busy worrying about what they will think of him – he assumes they will find him “dumb,” “boring,” or a “loser.” When he loses his concentration, he stutters, is at a loss for words, and starts to sweat, which only serves to make him feel more uneasy. After the interaction, he replays the conversation over and over again, focusing on the “stupid” things he said. Similarly, he has a long-standing history of being uncomfortable with authority figures and has had a hard time raising his hand in class and approaching teachers. Since starting college, he has been isolating more, turning down invitations from his roommate to go eat or hang out, ignoring his cell phone when it rings, and habitually skipping class. His concerns about how others view him are what drive him to engage in these avoidance behaviors.

Sample Solution

Potential Diagnoses:

  • Social Anxiety Disorder (SAD): J.T.’s fear of negative evaluation in social situations, avoidance behaviors, and physical symptoms like stuttering and sweating align with symptoms of SAD.
  • Depression: His feelings of worthlessness (“loser”), low motivation, anhedonia (lack of pleasure), and social isolation are all signs of depression.

Cognitive Distortions:

J.T. appears to be engaging in negative automatic thoughts (NATs) and cognitive distortions, such as:

  • Mind Reading: Assuming others will think poorly of him without evidence.
  • Fortune Telling: Predicting negative outcomes (“probably flunk out”).
  • Filtering: Focusing on negative aspects of interactions and ignoring positive ones.
  • Magnification and Minimization: Exaggerating his flaws and minimizing his strengths (“stupid things”).

Critical Thinking Considerations:

  • Comorbidity: It’s common for mental health conditions to co-occur. J.T.’s symptoms suggest both SAD and depression might be present.
  • History and Onset: Understanding the timeline of his shyness and how it intensified in college helps tailor treatment.
  • Cultural Context: Social anxiety can manifest differently in various cultures.

Treatment and Health Promotion using Evidence-Based Research

Treatment Options:

  • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): CBT is highly effective for both SAD and depression. It can help J.T. identify and challenge his negative thoughts, develop coping mechanisms for social anxiety, and build social skills.
  • Exposure Therapy: This therapy gradually exposes J.T. to feared social situations in a safe and controlled environment, helping him manage anxiety and build confidence.
  • Medication: Antidepressants may be considered to address his low mood and improve motivation for therapy.

Health Promotion Strategies:

  • Social Skills Training: Developing communication skills and strategies for initiating conversations can empower J.T. to connect with others.
  • Stress Management Techniques: Relaxation techniques like deep breathing and mindfulness meditation can help J.T. manage his anxiety and improve focus.
  • Building a Support System: Encouraging J.T. to reconnect with his friends and reach out to his college’s mental health resources can provide emotional support and a sense of belonging.

Importance of Evidence-Based Research:

The treatment approaches mentioned above are all supported by extensive research. Using evidence-based practices increases the likelihood of positive outcomes for J.T.

Additional Considerations:

  • Collaboration: Mental health professionals like therapists and psychiatrists work together to develop the most effective treatment plan for J.T.
  • Holistic Approach: Addressing J.T.’s academic struggles alongside his mental health can be crucial for his overall well-being.

By applying critical thinking skills to analyze J.T.’s situation and utilizing evidence-based treatment approaches, we can create a comprehensive plan to help him manage his anxiety and depression, improve his social interactions, and increase his overall well-being.

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer