Evaluating Sources for a Historical Topic

 

 

 

 

 

 

Skill(s) Being Assessed: Problem Solving
• Criteria for Success: In this assignment, you will:
• Identify sources relevant to your topic.
• Identify key elements of the documents (who, what, when, why).
• Effectively identify biases and perspectives of your sources.
• Effectively identify facts present in the sources.
• Effectively identify why the source is credible.
What to submit/deliverables: Questions submitted in Chapter 3 of the webtext.
What is the value of doing this assignment? This assignment gives you an opportunity to practice the skill of problem solving. It will show that you can find and evaluate relevant, reliable, and credible sources. Problem solving is a universal skill and one you will continue to refine as you progress throughout your career. This assignment asks you to use what you’ve learned in the first three weeks of the course about finding and evaluating sources. Worried about where to start? The good news is that you’ve already laid the foundation with the webtext activities in Chapters 1 and 2. This assignment will use what you wrote in those activities to help you record your response.
Your goal for this assignment is to: Practice your problem solving skill. You will do this by applying what you know about sourcing to evaluate sources on your chosen topic.
What you need to complete this assignment:
• Your chosen issue and topic from Chapters 1 and 2 of the webtext.
• The answers you provided in Chapter 3 of the webtext.
• Your completed assignment, downloaded from Chapter 3 of the webtext and uploaded and submitted to Assignment 1 in Week 3 of Blackboard.
Steps to complete: In Week 3, complete the assignment and submit it to the Week 3 Assignment 1 link in Blackboard using the following steps:
STEP 1: Review the scenario:
Imagine you represent your company at a service organization dealing with one of these two issues: Facing Economic Change or Engaging Civil Rights. Your supervisor has asked you to research information related to the history of one of these issues for your organization to help new employees and volunteers understand it better. Your predecessor already started a list of sample primary and secondary sources and collections of sources.
In this assignment, you will take the first step in creating your presentation to help new employees and volunteers understand how historical events can be applied to one of the issues currently affecting your organization. To do the research necessary for your presentation, you will need to choose four sources that are credible and relevant for the issue facing your organization.
STEP 2: Using the writing templates in Chapters 1 and 2 of the webtext, you will select the specific issue or topic you want to address and identify key words that can focus your search for and identification of sources.
STEP 3: Then, from a collection of sources, you will choose two primary and two secondary sources that have relevant information for the historical events you want to include in your presentation. To put together your list of sources, the webtext writing templates will guide you through a set of questions to evaluate the credibility of each one.
STEP 4: Download the assignment from the webtext and upload it to Assignment 1 in Week 3 of Blackboard.

Sample Solution

have instated a Communist regime, was widely spread and, as Folch-Serra argues ‘systematically enforced through schools and textbooks, the pulpit, the Fascist institutions and the media’ (p. 228). There was heavy censorship of news that could have challenged this image, which Folch-Serra shows was ‘illustrated by the Spanish media’s disregard of the Nobel prizes awarded to Juan Ramón Jiménez for literature in 1956 and Severo Ochoa for science in 1959’ (p. 229). This leads on to the contradictory nature of Franco’s treatment of the Republicans since, as well as spreading defamatory comments about their nature, there was also, as Folch-Serra explains, a ‘suppression of information about their fate and whereabouts’ (p. 229) which drew from a ‘deliberate policy of oblivion and silence’ (p. 229). By winning the Civil War, Franco also won the fortune of being able to rewrite history and, as Folch-Serra confirms, he was able to ‘concoct a uniform image of the defeated as one and the same’ (p. 227). Amongst other forms of propaganda, education allowed Franco to disseminate his version of events as truth, which can be seen through school textbooks which Xavier Laudo elaborates on how they ‘spoke of the desertion of Republican soldiers’ as well as presenting Republican Spain as the ‘enemy within’ (p. 442) who were ‘responsible for the erosion of the nation’s Christian faith’ (p. 442). Assmann further shows how this ‘one sided version of history’ (p. 64) not only ‘protected’ (p. 65) and legitimised Franco, but also ‘prolonged the enemy stereotype of the murdered communists and democrats’ (p. 65). Thus, it can be seen that Franco manipulated the memory of the Civil War during his dictatorship and how his policies towards the Republicans after the war allowed him to promote his narrative as the truth and legitimise his position. This collective amnesia that Franco wanted to induce, discredited and erased his opponent from history. However, Assmann adds that this ‘silence did not dissolve the memory of the traumatic past’ (p. 66) and did not fully discredit his opponents, as individual memories of the events were ‘materially preserved in the earth and in families’ (p. 66). Memory also featured heavily in Franco’s propaganda, with many references made to returning Spain to the greatness it had once experienced. Franco’s message regarding the Republicans was spread through education and Laudo explains that so was the image of the Civil War as a ‘crusade’ (p. 438) such as during the Middle Ages. Zheng Wang describes how school textbooks can be used as ‘instruments for glorifying the nation, consolidating its national identity and justifying particular forms of social and political systems ‘ and how the rewriting of school textbooks can be used to ‘legitimise the new regime’ (p. 45). This is evident on the front cover of El Libro de España, which features a boat sailing across the globe, against the backdrop of the Spanish flag. This reminds the viewer of the Spanish Empire, as Laudo confirms, ‘stressing the cross-Atlantic colonialist adventures in the Americas’ (p. 443), and the power and glory that this brought, ‘promoting a spirit of patriotism’ (p.443). Through this, Laudo explains that Franco was able to propagate his ‘vision of Spain’s history, its Hispanic mission for imperial glory’ (p. 453). Religious references were frequently seen in Franco’s propaganda, and comparisons were made to the Catholic monarchs and the unity and greatness Spain experienced under them. Miriam

This question has been answered.

Get Answer
WeCreativez WhatsApp Support
Our customer support team is here to answer your questions. Ask us anything!
👋 Hi, Welcome to Compliant Papers.