Cecil Rhodes, “Confession of Faith.”(1877)
Winston Churchill, excerpts from The River War: An Account of the Conquest of the Sudan. (1902)
Mohandas K. Gandhi, excerpts from Hind Swarj. (Indian Home Rule, 1910)
For this module’s discussion, read each of the primary source excerpts above, then choose ONE of the three readings to make a discussion post answering both of the following two questions:
1. How does the author describe the differences between the Western conquerors and the inhabitants of the countries that were conquered?
2. According to the author, what were the most important consequences of the encounter between these two groups?
Churchill describes the Western conquerors as superior to the inhabitants of the countries that were conquered. He uses a variety of language to do this, including:
Churchill believes that the most important consequence of the encounter between the Western conquerors and the inhabitants of the countries that were conquered was the spread of Western civilization. He writes that the British had a “duty to civilize” the Sudanese. He believed that this duty was more important than any other consideration, including the rights of the Sudanese people.
Churchill also believes that another important consequence of the encounter between the Western conquerors and the inhabitants of the countries that were conquered was the establishment of British rule. He believed that British rule was beneficial to the Sudanese people, because it brought them peace, order, and good government.
However, Churchill acknowledges that the encounter between the Western conquerors and the inhabitants of the countries that were conquered also had some negative consequences. For example, he writes that the British conquest of the Sudan led to the loss of life of many Sudanese people. He also acknowledges that the British conquest of the Sudan disrupted Sudanese culture and society.
Churchill’s The River War: An Account of the Conquest of the Sudan is a classic example of British imperialist literature. Churchill’s descriptions of the Western conquerors and the inhabitants of the countries that were conquered are highly biased and reflect the racist and paternalistic attitudes that were common among British imperialists at the time.
Churchill’s views on the consequences of the encounter between the Western conquerors and the inhabitants of the countries that were conquered are also highly biased. He emphasizes the positive consequences, such as the spread of Western civilization and the establishment of British rule, and downplays the negative consequences, such as the loss of life and the disruption of culture and society.
It is important to read Churchill’s book with a critical eye and to be aware of his biases. However, the book is still a valuable source of information about British imperialism and the conquest of the Sudan.