How have historians tended to define “politics” over the course of American history? When and why have these definitions changed and varied? What impact do these definitions have on how historians have approached and written about the nation’s past?
Traditionally, historians have defined politics narrowly as the activities of government, including elections, legislation, and foreign policy. This definition was dominant in the early years of American historical writing, and it reflected the prevailing view that politics was the exclusive domain of white men of property.
However, over time, historians have come to adopt a broader definition of politics that encompasses all aspects of human interaction that involve the distribution of power and resources. This broader definition includes social movements, popular culture, and even personal relationships.
The shift to a broader definition of politics was driven by a number of factors, including:
When and why have these definitions changed and varied?
As noted above, the definition of politics has changed and varied over time in response to a number of factors, including the rise of new social movements, the development of new historical subfields, and the growing recognition that politics is not simply about the formal activities of government.
Here are some specific examples of how the definition of politics has changed and varied over the course of American history:
What impact do these definitions have on how historians have approached and written about the nation’s past?
The definition of politics has a significant impact on how historians have approached and written about the nation’s past. A narrow definition of politics leads historians to focus on the formal activities of government and the experiences of the elite. A broader definition of politics leads historians to focus on the experiences of marginalized groups and on the ways in which power is exercised in everyday life.
For example, a historian who uses a narrow definition of politics might write a book about the presidency of George Washington. The historian would focus on Washington’s political decisions and policies. They might also discuss his relationships with other Founding Fathers and the challenges of governing a new nation.
A historian who uses a broader definition of politics might write a book about the impact of the American Revolution on women’s lives. The historian would focus on the ways in which women participated in the Revolution and the ways in which the Revolution changed their lives. They might also discuss the ways in which women’s experiences of the Revolution shaped their political views in the years that followed.
The following are some specific examples of how the definition of politics has influenced how historians have written about American history:
The labor movement of the late 19th and early 20th centuries led to a renewed interest among historians in the role of workers