Religion And Ethics

 

 

1. What is the relation between ethics and religion? Formulate and investigate the relation.

2. For each case, determine the ethical path of conduct. Then, determine what paths of conduct would be unethical

3. For each case, what would an emotivism say to appraise what you determine is the ethical form of conduct?

4. For each case, would a natural law ethicist agree with what you say is the ethical form of conduct? Why or why not?

5. Articulate, explain, and evaluate in each case an approach that makes use of divine command ethics.

Sample Solution

The relationship between ethics and religion is complex and multifaceted. Here’s an exploration of the connection:

  • Shared Focus on Morality: Both ethics and religion are concerned with defining right and wrong behavior. They aim to guide individuals towards actions that benefit themselves and society.
  • Basis of Morality: Ethics often relies on reason and logic to determine right and wrong. Religion, on the other hand, typically grounds morality in divine revelation or sacred texts.
  • Potential for Overlap: Religious teachings often align with core ethical principles like honesty, compassion, and justice. Religious doctrines can provide a foundation for ethical behavior.
  • Potential for Conflict: There can be situations where religious beliefs and ethical principles clash. For example, a religion might condone practices considered unethical by secular standards.

Investigating the Relationship:

Here are some approaches to explore the connection between ethics and religion:

  • Comparative Ethics: Compare the ethical codes of different religions and identify commonalities and differences.
  • Philosophical Analysis: Examine how religious justifications for morality compare to secular ethical frameworks.
  • Psychological Studies: Explore the role of religion in shaping moral behavior and decision-making.

Ethical Case Studies

Case 1: You find a wallet containing a large sum of money.

  • Ethical Path: Return the wallet to its owner or turn it in to the authorities.
  • Unethical Path: Keep the money for yourself.

Emotivism: An emotivist might say the ethical path evokes positive emotions like honesty and kindness, while keeping the money evokes negative emotions like selfishness and dishonesty.

Natural Law Ethicist: A natural law ethicist might agree, arguing that returning the wallet aligns with the inherent human good of respecting others’ property.

Divine Command Ethics: This approach suggests the ethical path aligns with following God’s commandments, which might include one prohibiting theft.

Case 2: You witness a friend cheating on an exam.

  • Ethical Path: Report the cheating or speak to your friend about the consequences.
  • Unethical Path: Remain silent and potentially benefit from your friend’s cheating (e.g., easier test curve).

Emotivism: Reporting the cheating might evoke negative emotions like guilt or betrayal, but it aligns with fairness and honesty.

Natural Law Ethicist: Natural law might suggest a duty to uphold academic integrity, making reporting the cheating the ethical path.

Divine Command Ethics: Many religions emphasize honesty and fairness, potentially advocating for reporting the cheating.

 

This question has been answered.

Get Answer