The disputation

1. What did Queen Yolanda and Raymond hope to accomplish by holding a disputation?

2. What is a disputation?

3. What condition allowed Rabbi Moshe to agree to participate?

4. What were the subjects covered by the debate/disputation?

5. In what ways do Jews and Christians understand the messiah differently?

6. What circumstances put an end to the debate?

7. How does the movie portray King James? (Character flaws, virtues)

8. What did you learn about medieval Christianity from this film?

Sample Solution

The disputation

The disputation or debate, one of many held in the medieval period, was held in June 1263. The dialogue in the movie was written by a Jewish scholar named Hyam Maccoby, but it was based on a pamphlet published by Rabbi Moshe son of Nachman Gerondi. Queen Maccoby`s tract examines the early years of the inquisition with only moderate results. The ordered disputation was organized by Raymond de Penyafort, the superior of Christiani and the confessor of James I. The disputation took place in front of the royal court of King James of Aragon, who guaranteed and asserted freedom of speech for the Jewish spokesperson Nachmanides. This led to genuine confrontation between Christianity and Judaism in which the true fundamental differences between the two religions could be brought to light.

tiation of Christianity in 337 AD by Constantine the Great as the definitive cause while others blame it on increases in unemployment, inflation, military expenditure and slave labour while others blame it on the ethical issues such the decline in morals, the lack of discipline of the armies and the political corruption within the Empire. Three major contributions that led to the collapse of the once great empire were: the heavy military spending in order to expand the Empire, the over-reliance on slave labour which led to an increase in unemployment, and the political corruption and abuse of power by the Praetorian Guard leading to the unfair selection of many disreputable emperors and the assassination of those not favoured by the Guard.

One of the main reasons of the collapse of the Roman Empire was the over expenditure on the military to constantly fund wars abroad. In order for the Romans to invade and conquer other provinces they had to spend heavily on their legions. The Roman armies and supply lines became over-stretched resulting in thousands of soldiers being recruited and deployed from Rome into other territories as invaders or defenders. They also depended on soldiers to defend the borders of the lands they had conquered from barbarian attacks which resulted in the increased manufacturing of weapons and more money being spent on soldiers. High military spending left the Romans with very limited resources for other essential government projects such as the building of more public houses and the development of roads and aqueducts as well as leading to inflation. The over-expenditure on the military led the citizens of Rome to refuse the policies and laws enforced by the government and riots were commonplace in Rome during its last century. Due to the Roman citizens growing distrust of the Empire less people volunteered to join their armies which forced the military to hire common criminals and non-Roman mercenaries. The government raised taxes to aid their military expenditure which added to the low morale of the Roman population with every citizen losing a third of their weekly wage. The money raised to spend taxes was wasted on soldiers who constantly had to be replaced until the Romans could no longer afford to send large garrisons of troops abroad leaving their own borders poorly defended and vulnerable to attacks. The non-Roman mercenaries were too proud to serve a weakening empire and they began to conquer parts of the Empire as the Romans were unable to afford to send detachments and reserves to reclaim these areas. The city of Rome was left very poorly defended due to the deployment of troops to other provinces within the Empire which were defeated and taken by the barbarians making it considerably easier for the

This question has been answered.

Get Answer
WeCreativez WhatsApp Support
Our customer support team is here to answer your questions. Ask us anything!
👋 Hi, Welcome to Compliant Papers.