The Great Depression

 

Where should we place the blame for the Great Depression?
Where should we place the blame? Economists believe the Great Depression was caused by the weaknesses in the 1920s economy, but the person whose name will be forever linked to the depression is President Herbert Hoover. Personally blaming him for the crisis, Americans started to call the shantytowns set up by unemployed people “Hoovervilles.”
In order to prepare for this discussion forum: line-height:
• Review and identify the relevant sections of Chapter 25 that address these topics and support your discussion.
• Read the linked essay DEBATING THE PAST: CAUSES OF THE GREAT DEPRESSION: Where Historians Disagree
• Read America’s Great Depression: www.amatecon.com/gd/gdcandc.html
• Read Digital History: Sections Why it Happened to President Hoover http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/teachers/lesson_plans/pdfs/unit9.pdf
After you have completed your readings post your response to only ONE of the following questions.
1. Hoover’s presidency will be forever shadowed by the Great Depression. Is it fair to blame Hoover’s actions or inaction for the Great Depression?
2. Should we compare Presidents Hoover and President Roosevelt’s attempts to deal with the depression?

Sample Solution

action when German troops re-militarizes the Rhineland in 1936 and for historian Ian Kershaw, the allies ‘let slip’ the last chance to stop Hitler and GB’s rearmament programme introduced by Chamberlain in 1936 was significantly behind Germany’s. Appeasement was the result of a belief that peaceful negotiation would bring security for Britain. The controversy stems from the simple fact that Chamberlain failed and Czechoslovakia was abandoned.

In a Parliamentary debate in October 1938 after the Munich Agreement had been signed, Winston Churchill, a strong critic of appeasement, stated ‘All is over, silent, mournful, abandoned, broken, Czechoslovakia recedes into the darkness’ highlighting the abandonment of a small state’s independence. Czechoslovakia lost 66 percent of of its coal industry, 70 percent of its iron and steel, and 70 percent of its electrical power, depriving the nation of natural fortifications that left the Czech nation open to complete domination by Germany. The autonomy of Czechoslovakia was sacrificed on the altar for short-term peace because, in the words of President Benes of Czechoslovakia, Sudetenland was ‘a long way from Great Britain and France’ and Germany had achieved what he wanted ‘the domination of Central Europe.’ The swift occupation of Moravia and Bohemia 6 months later and GB’s guarantee to Poland in the hope of making Hitler re-think, failed and war was declared. As early as 1940, the publication of Guilty Men by CATO spurned the policy of appeasement, criticising Chamberlain for ‘cowardice, a lack of wisdom and disregard of the principle of freedom and democracy’ as the expansionism of the Nazi regime and the nature of Nazi rule became all too apparent. Historian R.A.C Parker suggests that Chamberlain manipulated the public opinion to favour appeasement, a view supported by historian, Frank McDonough who argues he “deliberately deceived British public opinion with overly optimistic accounts of the prospects for lasting peace with Germany” and by preventing war over

This question has been answered.

Get Answer