How important are the perceptions of others in determining the status of a person in Wilderson’s essay? When people think of an animal as a pet, rather than as food in Orleans’ article, are they attributing personality to the pet and making them a person
In his essay “On the Social Death of Black People,” Frank Wilderson argues that the status of a person is determined by the perceptions of others. He writes that “the social death of black people is the condition of being ungrievable,” meaning that black people are not seen as fully human and therefore their lives do not matter. This is because black people have been historically denied the right to self-determination and have been subjected to violence and oppression.
The perceptions of others are also important in determining the status of animals. In her article “What Is a Pet?” Catherine Orleans argues that when people think of an animal as a pet, rather than as food, they are attributing personality to the animal and making it a person. She writes that “pets are not simply objects that we own; they are beings with their own thoughts, feelings, and desires.”
Orleans’ argument is supported by research on animal cognition. Studies have shown that animals are capable of complex emotions, such as love, grief, and joy. They also have a sense of self and can form social bonds with other animals and humans.
The fact that animals are capable of experiencing emotions and forming social bonds suggests that they should not be treated as objects. However, in many cultures, animals are still seen as property and are treated accordingly. They are often subjected to violence and exploitation, just like black people.
The perceptions of others are therefore very important in determining the status of both people and animals. When people see black people as less than human and animals as property, they are denying them their basic humanity and dignity. This is a form of oppression that must be challenged.
In conclusion, the perceptions of others are very important in determining the status of both people and animals. When people see black people as less than human and animals as property, they are denying them their basic humanity and dignity. This is a form of oppression that must be challenged.
Here are some additional thoughts on the topic: