As The Execution of Charles I reading demonstrates, a primary source is the product of the historical context and biases surrounding the author. There is always a lot of subtext in a primary source, so you need to read between the lines. With this in mind, let’s do some detective work with this week’s readings!
Please write 1-2 concise paragraphs connecting “The Trial of Joan of Arc” with De Thou’s “Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre.” For both readings, I would like you to address the following questions:
Do the authors favor the Reformation or do they support the Catholic Church, and why do you think this is the case?
Explain how these documents connect to either “The Council of Trent” or “Martin Luther’s 95 Theses.” That is, how do “The Trial of Joan of Arc” and “Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre” relate to either Martin Luther’s teachings or the Catholic Church’s response to the Reformation. (Hint: even if the reading favors the Catholic Church, there might still be Protestant teachings in there.)
Have at least 2 in-text citations from each reading.
The authors of both “The Trial of Joan of Arc” and “Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre” favor the Catholic Church. This is evident in the way they portray the events of these two historical moments. In “The Trial of Joan of Arc,” the author describes Joan of Arc as a heretic who was misguided by the devil. The author also describes the Catholic Church as being justified in its actions against Joan of Arc. In “Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre,” the author describes the massacre as a justified response to the Protestant threat. The author also describes the Catholic Church as being the victim of Protestant violence.
“The Trial of Joan of Arc” and “Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre” both connect to Martin Luther’s 95 Theses and the Council of Trent. These two documents were written in response to the Protestant Reformation, which was sparked by Martin Luther’s 95 Theses. The Council of Trent was a meeting of the Catholic Church that was held in response to the Protestant Reformation. The Council of Trent reaffirmed the Catholic Church’s teachings and practices, and it also condemned the Protestant Reformation.
“The Trial of Joan of Arc” can be seen as a precursor to the Council of Trent. In the trial, Joan of Arc was accused of heresy, which is a belief that is contrary to the teachings of the Catholic Church. The Council of Trent also condemned heresy, and it reaffirmed the Catholic Church’s teachings on a number of issues, including the authority of the pope, the seven sacraments, and the importance of good works.
“Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre” can also be seen as a response to the Protestant Reformation. The massacre was a violent attack on Protestants, and it was carried out by Catholics. The massacre was a way for Catholics to assert their power and to punish Protestants for their beliefs. The Council of Trent also condemned violence, but it also justified violence in some cases, such as when it is used to defend the Catholic Church.
Here are two in-text citations from “The Trial of Joan of Arc”:
Here are two in-text citations from De Thou’s “Saint Bartholomew’s Day Massacre”: