The theoretical framework is a critical element of your work. A theoretical framework is the general representation of relationships in your problem and is based on existing theory. The conceptual framework is your idea on how the problem should be explored, and it is generally based on a theory. The difference between the two is the scope. Theory is broad; concept is narrow.
In most research studies, your framework can be either theoretical or conceptual in nature. For the purposes of this project, you will most likely follow a conceptual framework, which is your idea on how the research problem will be explored (although you could have both).
For example:
Theoretical framework: Stimulus is applied to elicit a response
Conceptual framework: A new teaching method is applied to elicit improvement in midterm test scores.
In this section of your change project, state the perspective through which the problem and/or phenomenon may be explored, and include the following:
Select a minimum of two theories.
Identify the process and logic in selecting these theoretical frameworks or conceptual frameworks for your study.
Discuss how each theory or model applies to the individual project.
Present the framework guiding your study.
Describe the assumptions of the framework.
Describe each key component of the framework.
Discuss how each element of the phenomenon applies to the framework.
Apply each element of the theory to the elements of the phenomenon under study.
Develop the rationale for the sample selection criteria.
Discuss, analyze, and critique pertinent research that uses the framework.
Remember that research never proves theory. Your research project can only support or refute the theoretical propositions you are using as your framework. But if you do not use theory or conceptual frameworks in your research, you may not be able to put your findings in a context that could strengthen the nursing education profession!
Let’s develop a theoretical framework for a change project aimed at reducing patient falls on a medical-surgical unit.
Theoretical Framework:
This change project will utilize a combined theoretical framework drawing upon two relevant theories:
The Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB): This theory, developed by Ajzen (1991), posits that an individual’s intention to perform a behavior is the most proximal determinant of that behavior. Intention is influenced by attitudes toward the behavior, subjective norms (perceived social pressure), and perceived behavioral control (belief in one’s ability to perform the behavior). TPB is relevant because it provides a framework for understanding the factors that influence nurses’ adherence to fall prevention protocols.
Donabedian’s Structure-Process-Outcome (SPO) Model: This model (Donabedian, 1966) is a widely used framework for evaluating healthcare quality. It emphasizes the interconnectedness of structure (resources and organizational characteristics), process (activities and interventions), and outcomes (results of care). The SPO model is applicable as it provides a framework for assessing the impact of a fall prevention intervention on patient outcomes.
Process and Logic of Theory Selection:
These theories were chosen because they offer complementary perspectives on behavior change and healthcare quality improvement. TPB provides a framework for understanding the individual and social factors influencing nurses’ behavior related to fall prevention, while the SPO model provides a framework for evaluating the impact of a fall prevention program on patient outcomes.
Application of Theories to the Project:
Framework Guiding the Study:
The framework guiding this study is a combination of TPB and the SPO model, visualized as follows:
Structure (Resources, Unit Culture)
^
|
|
v
Personal Factors <----------------------------> Process (Fall Prevention Practices)
(Attitudes, Subjective Norms, Perceived (Adherence to protocols, use of equipment)
Behavioral Control) ^
|
|
v
Outcomes (Patient Falls)
Assumptions of the Framework:
Key Components of the Framework:
Application of Elements to the Phenomenon:
Applying Theory to Elements:
Rationale for Sample Selection Criteria:
The sample will consist of registered nurses working on a medical-surgical unit with a high rate of patient falls. This population is chosen because they are directly involved in patient care and are the target of the intervention.
Pertinent Research Using the Framework:
Research on fall prevention in hospitals often utilizes elements of TPB and the SPO model. Studies have shown that interventions targeting nurses’ attitudes and beliefs can improve adherence to fall prevention protocols (e.g., [cite a relevant study]). Research on the impact of fall prevention programs on patient outcomes also aligns with the SPO model (e.g., [cite another relevant study]). A critical analysis of this research will be included in the project.